The most unique jewelry stores in America

There are thousands of places to shop for jewelry, but only a few stores feel like magic when you walk in. They're owned and staffed by friendly, highly experienced people who know how to help you find exactly what you're looking for.

These stores carry jewelry that doesn't look like what you see in a mall chain store. Some of these stores have small, curated collections. Some carry antique jewelry. All these stores carry jewelry designed and handcrafted by artists. 

This is the beginning of a list of these special jewelry stores.
It's a work in progress. Help me make this an awesome list! Tell me about your favorite store in the comments below and I'll add it.

Stores are listed by State and in alphabetical order:


August, Los Angeles Jewelry Store

8311 1/2 West Third Street
Los Angeles, CA 90048

Owner: Bill Hermsen
Instagram: @augustlosangeles


Broken English Jewelry California
Broken English

225 26th Street, #17
Santa Monica, CA 90402

Owner: Laura Freedman
Instagram: @brokenenglishjewelry


De Novo Jewelry in Palo Alto, California
De Novo

250 University Avenue
Palo Alto, CA 94301
Owner: Cherry LeBrun
Instagram: @denovo_finecontemporaryjewelry


Fiat Lux Jewelry, San Francisco, CA
Fiat Lux
3169 16th Street
San Francisco, CA 94103
Owner: Marie McCarthy
Instagram: @fiatluxsf


General Store home and jewelry store, San Francisco and Venice, CA
General Store

4035 Judah Street
San Francisco, CA 94122
1801 Lincoln Boulevard
Venice, CA 90291
Owners: Serena Mitnik-Miller & Mason St. Peter
Instagram: @generalstore


Metier, Jewelry store in San Francisco, CA

Hayes Valley
546 Laguna Street
San Francisco, CA 94102
Owners: Sheri Evans & Trina Papini
Instagram: @metiersf 


Reliquary in San Francisco, CA
544 Hayes Street
San Francisco, CA 94102
Owner: Leah Bershad
Instagram: @reliquarysf


Roseark Jewelry in West Hollywood, CA
1111 N. Crescent Heights Boulevard
West Hollywood, CA 90046
Owner: Kathy Rose
Instagram: @roseark


Shibumi Jewelry Gallery in Berkeley, California
1816 Fourth Street
Berkeley, CA 94710
Owner: April Higashi
Instagram: @shibumi_gallery


Sofia Jewelry, Mill Valley, California
Sofia Jewelry
80 Throckmorton Avenue
Mill Valley, CA 94941
Owner: Carl, Lucas and Sophie Priolo
Instagram: @sofiajewelry


Tail of the Yak store in Berkeley, CA
Tail of the Yak
2632 Ashby Avenue
Berkeley, CA 94705
Owners: Alice Erb & Lauren McIntosh
Instagram: @tailoftheyakstore


The Jewelry Bar in Palm Desert
The Jewelry Bar

73255 El Paseo
Palm Desert, CA 92260
Owner: Ryan Ryan



Signet Jewelry in Denver, Colorado
Element 79 Jewelry

300 Fillmore Street
Denver, CO 80206
Owner: Carol Ferguson
Instagram: @element79jewelry



Mia Gemma, Washington DC Jewelry Store
Mia Gemma

Washington, DC
Owner: Irene Barbieri
Instagram: @mia_gemma_jewels



Laughing Dog Gallery in Vero Beach, Florida
Laughing Dog

2910 Cardinal Drive
Vero Beach, FL 32963
Owner: Susie & Jeffery Wilber
Instagram: @thelaughingdoggallery



Gem Jewelry Boutique in Oak Park, IL

135 North Oak Park Avene
Oak Park, IL 60301
Owner: Laura Kitsos
Instagram: @gemjewelryboutique


Sailor Jewelry Store in Chicago, IL

4658 North Damen Avenue
Chicago, IL 60625
Owners: Sarah McGuire
Instagram: @shop-sailor



Asiatica clothing and jewelry store in Kansas

4824 Rainbow Boulevard
Westwood, KS 66205 

Owner: Elizabeth Wilson
Instagram: @asiaticakc



Shaw Jewelry in Northest Harbor, Maine
Shaw Jewelry
128 Main Street
Northeast Harbor, ME 04662
Owner: Sam Shaw
Instagram: @shawjewelry



DMG Gallery in Northampton, Massachusetts

40 Main Street
Northampton, MA 01060
Owner: Maya MacLachlan
Instagram: @_shopberyl


E.R. Butler & Co. jewelry in Boston MA

E.R. Butler & Co.
38 Charles Street
Boston, MA 02114
Owner: Rhett Butler


Fire Opal Gallery in Massachusetts
Fire Opal
320 Harvard Street
Brookline, MA 02446
Owners: Sue Stein & Steve Murakishi
Instagram: @fireopalboston


Gladstone Jewelry in Manchester-by-the-Sea
36 1/2 Union Street
Manchester-by-the-Sea, MA 01944
Owners: Elaine Souza & Charles Gladstone
Instagram: @gladstonejewelry


Mobilia Gallery in Cambridge, MA
Mobilia Gallery

348 Huron Avenue
Cambridge, MA 02138
Owners: Joanne & Libby Cooper
Instagram: @mobiliagallery


Motto Jewelry, Accessories and Home store in Cambridge, MA

26 Church Street
Cambridge, MA 02138
Owner: Kim Teirlynck
Instagram: @mottoharvardsq


Patina Jewelry, Nantucket, MA

23 Centre Street
Nantucket, MA 02554
Owner: Carol Muehling 
Instagram: @patinanantucket


Quadrum Gallery in Boston Massachusetts

199 Boyston Street
Chestnut Hill, MA 02467
Owner: Cynthia Kagan
Instagram: @quadrumgallery



Metal Art Studio Jewelry in Grand Rapids, Michigan
Metal Art Studio

978 Cherry St SE
Grand Rapids, MI 49506
Owner: Scott Carey
Instagram: @metal_art_studio 



Alara Jewelry in Bozeman, Montana
Alara Jewelry
42 W. Main Street
Bozeman, MT 59715
Owner: Babs Noelle
Instagram: @alarajewelry



Patina jewelry gallery, Santa Fe, NM
Patina Gallery

131 West Palace Avenue 
Santa Fe, 
NM 87501
Owners: Allison & Ivan Barnett
Instagram: @patinagallery



Broken English Jewelry Store in New York
Broken English

56 Crosby Street
New York, 
NY 10012
Owner: Laura Freedman
Instagram: @brokenenglishjewelry


Catbird Jewelry in Brooklyn, New York

219 Bedford Avenue
Brooklyn, NY 11211
Owner: Rony Vardi
Instagram: @catbirdnyc


DeVera Jewelry & Objects, New York City

1 Crosby Street
New York, NY 10013
Owner: Federico de Vera
Instagram: @deverany


E.R. Butler hardware and jewelry store, NYC
E.R. Butler & Co
55 Prince Street
New York, NY 10012
Owner: Rhett Butler


Facets of Earth Jewelry in Kingston, NY Rondout neighborhood
Facets of Earth

22 Broadway Avenue
Kingston, NY 12401
Owner: Morgan Mikula
Instagram: @facetsofearth


Green Cottage, jewelry store in High Falls, NY
Green Cottage
1204 Route 213
High Falls, NY 12440
Owners: Dennis Nutley & David Urso
Instagram: @greencottagehighfalls


Hudson Valley Goldsmith in New Paltz, New York
Hudson Valley Goldsmith

71A Main Street
New Paltz, NY 12561
Owners: David & Sara Walton
Instagram: @hudsonvalleygoldsmith


Hummingbird Jewelers in Rhinebeck, NY
Hummingbird Jewelers

23A East Market Street
Rhinebeck, NY 12572
Owners: Bruce & Peggy Lubman
Instagram: @hummingbirdjewelersgallery


Love Adorned Jewelry in New York
Love Adorned

269 Elizabeth Street 
New York, NY 10012
Amagansett Square
156 Main Street
Amagansett, NY 11930
Owner: Lori Leven
Instagram: @loveadorned


Mayer Wasner, Narrowsburg, NY Jewelry Store
Mayer Wasner

55 Main Street
Narrowsburg, NY 12764
Owner: Pamela Mayer
Instagram: @mayerwasner


The Store at MAD Museum in New York
Museum of Arts & Design

2 Columbus Circle
New York, NY 10019
Instagram: @thestoreatmad


Hudson, NY, Jewelry Gallery Ornamentum

506 Warren Street
Hudson, NY 12534
Owners: Laura Lapachin & Stefan Friedemann
Instagram: @ornamentum_gallery

Paper Trail in the village of Rhinebeck
Paper Trail

6423 Montgomery Street
Rhinebeck, NY 12572
Owners: Serine Hastings & Maureen Missner
Instagram: @papertrailrhinebeck
Read more about Paper Trail...


Peridot Fine Jewelry in Larchmont, New York
1903 Palmer Avenue
Larchmont, NY 10538
Owner: Dawn Hendricks
Instagram: @peridotfinejewelry



Mora Jewelry in Asheville North Carolina

9 West Walnut Street, Suite 2A
Asheville, NC 28801
Owner: Marthe Le Van
Instagram: @morajewelry



Ombré Jewelry Gallery in Cincinnati, Ohio
Ombré Gallery

1511 Race Street
Cincinnati, OH
Owner: Jenna Shaifer
Instagram: @ombregallery



Jewelry store TWIST in Portland, Oregon

30 NW 23rd Place
Portland, OR 97210
University Village
4618 26th Avenue NE
Seattle, WA 98105
Owners: Paul Schneider & Lauren Eulau
Instagram: @twistonline



Meeka Fine Jewelry in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania
Meeka Fine Jewelry
2135 Market Street
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Owner: Monika Krol
Instagram: @meekafinejewelry



RTW clothing and jewelry store in Charleston, SC
186 King Street
Charleston, SC 29401
Owner: Janyce McMenamin
Instagram: @rtwcharleston



Amanda Pinson Jewelry in Chattanooga, Tennessee
Amanda Pinson Jewelry
1110 Market Street
Chattanooga, TN 37208
Owner: Amanda Pinson
Instagram: @amandapinsonjewelry



Eliza Page jewelry in Austin, Texas
Eliza Page

229 W 2nd Street
Austin, TX 78701
Owner: Elizabeth Page
Instagram: @elizapagejewelry


Grange Hall home objects and jewelry in Dallas, TX
Grange Hall
4445 Travis Street
Dallas, TX 75205
Owners: Rajan Patel & Jeffrey Lee
Instagram: @ufgrangehall


Jewelry at High Gloss store in Houston, TX
High Gloss

1131-06 Uptown Park Blvd.
Houston, TX 77056
Owners: Kim & Lisa Glosserman
Instagram: @highglosshouston


Shetler Fine Jewelers in San Antonio, Texas
Shetler Fine Jewelers
1131-06 Uptown Park Blvd.
Houston, TX 77056
Owner: Michelle Shetler
Instagram: @shetlerfinejewelers


Szor Collections jewelry store in Dallas TX
Szor Collections

6131 Luther Lane, Suite 210
Dallas, TX 75225

Owner: Jay Szor
Instagram: @szorcollections


Jewelry store Ylang 23 in Dallas, Texas

The Plaza at Preston Center
8300 Preston Road (at Northwest Highway), Suite 700
Dallas, TX 75225
Owner: Joanne & Charles Teichman
Instagram: @ylang23



Nine Roses Jewelry store in Richmond, Virginia
Nine Roses Jewelers
19 North Belmont Avenue
Richmond, VA 23221
Owners: Nick & Eliza DeRosa
Instagram: @nineroses



Leave a comment

Please note, comments must be approved before they are published